Animal conservation: the debate
Debates organised by the Earth Focus Foundation and ICVolunteers
16 April 2008
On the 15th of April 2008, the International Conference Centre of Geneva hosted a lively youth debate on animal conservation, organised by the Earth Focus Foundation and ICVolunteers. Students from public and private schools in Geneva were invited to the debate. In addition, 10 students from the Aga Khan Academy from Mombassa, Kenya, also participated. ICV volunteers took care of contacts and liaising with schools, onsite logistics and reporting.
How can we understand better what threats endangered species are facing? Why is it important to protect them? These were the principal issues at stake during the conference.
The case studies: a map of endangered speciesThe case studies: a map of endangered species
The debate continued with the presentation of 8 case studies made by students from the International School of Geneva and the CollÃ¨ge du Leman.
The first group of students explained to the audience the case of the Blue Whale. The blue whale is the biggest mammal that ever lived on earth. It is endangered because of climate-change, maritime traffic, illegal hunting and pollution (such as oil spills, but also sound pollution). In 1930 there were an estimated 175,000 blue whales. In 2001 there were only about 1,000 left. "As all of the above are man-made problems, it's up to humans to solve them," added the speaker. "Blue whales are starting to go up in numbers a little bit," commented Mr ViÃ©, "but the problem is that when the numbers go up, people think it's Ok to start hunting them again!".
The Bengal Tiger is the 2nd largest species of tiger and one of the most endangered species in the world, even if it is a predator on top of the food chain. The Bengal tiger is in danger primarily due to rain forest destruction, but also because of hunting: tiger's body parts are used in traditional medicine and skin is sold to the USA and Europe. Today there are only 40,000 Bengal tigers left.
From the Red Panda group, the assembly learned that this animal is about the size of a cat and eats mostly bamboo. There are only about 2500 red panda left in China, India, Bhutan and Tibet, and their main enemies are men (who massacre the panda for his skin and destroy his habitat) and the snow leopard. To stop deforestation, the use of bio-fuels, recycling and the introduction of stricter laws against poaching are some of the actions which could be taken.
The Bumble bee - which is much less aggressive than an ordinary bee and produces very little honey - is endangered mostly because of pesticides and skunks, while the Polar Bear suffers from the destruction of his natural habitat, global warming, the exploitation of oil and gas, and the pollution of waters. There are about 20-25,000 polar bears left in the arctic.
Alizeh Jaffrey next presented the case of the Pink Dolphin, which at birth is not pink, but almost black, and gradually turns pink because of its diet, which contains pigments it cannot digest. There are only about 120 pink dolphins left. They live near river mouths, where the water is brackish. They don't migrate if the water gets polluted because they can't swim through salty water. This makes them very vulnerable. Pink dolphins are endangered because of pollution (untreated sewage is dumped into the water in great quantities), DDT (which passes through the mother's milk and kills baby fish), fishing (which often causes the accidental death of dolphins) and hunting (because their meat is rare and expensive). "To save pink dolphins sewage needs to be better treated, alternatives to DDT should be found, better net sizes should be used, fisherman should be more careful maneuvering their boats and laws against slaughter should be stricter."
The following case (which was given an award because it was the most balanced, accurate and original in its content) was about the Proboscis monkey. This monkey is unique and very special, with its big nose that regulates heat and attracts females. It eats leaves, flowers and insects and has a complex digestive system, which can handle cellulose and deal with toxins in plants. Its stomach represents a quarter of its weight! Borneo Island is the natural habitat of the Proboscis monkey. Due to deforestation and forest fires there are only 1,000 specimens left in the world and the situation is getting worse every year. "The monkeys are also kept in zoos,' explained the speaker, "but this is not really a solution, as they are social animals. The main advantage of keeping them in zoos is that captive breeding is good and maybe they can then be taken back to the wild".
The last speech was given by a student from the Aga Khan Academy (Mombassa, Kenya) and presented the case of endangered animals in Kenya. Animals such as the Sea Turtle and Dugong (Sea Cow) which are poached for their skins, tusks, oil and meat, and to make clothing and medicine, said the speaker. The last recorded sighting of a dugong in Kenya was in 1999, and it is not known how many specimens exist in the wild. We only know that there are five in captivity. Some protection schemes are urgently needed such as land allocation (reserves), regular clean-up of beaches, patrolling of water, laws against poaching and species education programmes in local communities and schools.
"It is hard to balance human needs with the needs of animals," concluded Mr ViÃ© in his final remarks "but we have to remember that each species is unique. It has taken thousands of years to evolve and cannot be replaced".
Posted: 2008-4-16 Updated: 2011-10-07